Showing posts with label Emerald Ash Borer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Emerald Ash Borer. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Minnesota May Release Wasps to Kill Emerald Ash Borer

Posted by Kirk 3 Comments
According to Gier Friisoe, division director for plant protection with the Minnesota Department of Agriculture, the state intends to release wasps as a biological control agent to help fight the Emerald Ash Borer infestation in the Twin Cities. When most people think about wasps they think of stings. With these wasps, the only species that needs to worry are the Ash Borers. As reported on Minnesota Public Radio, Friisoe said, "In China, where emerald ash borer [are] native, some of these stingless wasps have been shown to parasitize up to 90 percent."

A similar experiment began in Michigan in 2007 and Indiana in 2008. Cliff Sadof, Purdue professor of entomology was quoted in 2008 as saying, "In China, these wasp species reduced EAB populations by 74 percent in ash trees that are native to North America." Not quite as impressive as the 90% figure thrown out there by Friisoe but a huge step in the right direction none the less.

The wasps can sense the beetle larve under the bark of the ash trees and they lay their eggs inside the beetle larve or inside the eggs which kills them.

When will the wasps be introduced? According to Minnesota Agriculture Department spokesman Michael Schommer there's no timetable for introduction. Wasps have already been released in Michigan and as noted above, Indiana, but it is too early to say how effective they will be. In all cases, no one is sure if our cold winters will kill the wasps. That would be a huge problem since the Emerald Ash Borer doesn't seem to mind the cold.

There isn't much information available as to what species are being used for these experiments. I was able to dig up a study published in The Great Lakes Entomologist, titled, "Exploratory Survey For the Emerald Ash Borer, Agrilus Planipennis (Coleoptera: Buprestidae), and its Natural Enemies in China." Two of the possible parasites for Emerald Ash Borers are Spathius sp. and Tetrastichus nov. sp. Spathius wasp larve feed on Emerald Ash Borer larve and kill them. They fed by inserting their mouth hooks through the body wall of the Emerald Ash Borer's abdomen. Several larve may attack each borer larve. The adult wasps are 3.5 to 4.5 mm long. Tetrastichus larva, by contrast, actually kill the borer larve from the the inside out. The Tetrastichus adults are also tiny, only 2.5 to 5 mm long.

It will be interesting to see if this biological control pans out in the long run. The ash borers certainly aren't going anywhere soon.

~Kirk

(Emerald Ash Borer photo credit: US Forest Service)
Read More

Monday, March 8, 2010

Emerald Ash Borer found in Minneapolis

Posted by Kirk
I'm taking it a little easy on the blogging this past month as waves of ill health take turns hitting everyone at our house. The end of cold season is just one reason I'll be happy to see spring really hit.

The news keeps on coming in no matter my health and just last week the Minnesota Department of Agriculture survey staff reported that they found 8 trees as of in Minneapolis confirmed to be infested with emerald ash borer. The team found both the S-shaped galleries and the D-shaped exit holes.

The trees are located in Tower Hill Park in the Prospect Hill Neighborhood. This is very close to the original infestation in St. Paul so this is likely part of the same incident and not really a new infestation.

"When we found the St. Paul infestation last May so close to the border of the two cities, we knew there was a good chance we'd find it in Minneapolis," said MDA Plant Protection Director Geir Friisoe. "That's why we included Hennepin County in the initial EAB quarantine, even though it had only been confirmed in Ramsey County."

For more information on the find, visit the Minnesota Department of Agriculture website.

~Kirk
Read More

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Fighting Emerald Ash Borer Could Harm Birds and Bees

Posted by Kirk 4 Comments
I learned something interesting while reading the City of St. Paul's EAB Response Management Plan. Treating trees for Emerald Ash Borer in Twin Cities could harm bird and bee populations. It all comes down to pesticide use. The city rejected allowing residents to use any pesticide they choose on publicly owned trees because of the potential environmental impact. Also, the city will only allow injection of pesticides into public trees such as those on boulevards by a trained professional and not spraying which is a good thing as far as environmental impact. Residents can treat their own trees with pesticides and the official policy of the city will be that, "City Forestry staff will provide residents available information on EAB pesticides when requested but will remain neutral on whether or not to use." The document does not makes clear what the "available information on EAB pesticides" will be. It could simply be a list that says which ones work or it could include information on the harm they can cause. The fact that they are going to remain neutral on whether or not residents should use them may indicate that they will not tell people about the harmful effects of the pesticides but perhaps I am wrong on this. The same document states that pesticide use is usually not cost effective in the long run and there are environmental risks. I hope they pass that information along to the public as what one person does in the city effects us all.

Most pesticides used to treat Emerald Ash Borer infestations contain Imidacloprid. Imidacloprid is the first pesticide in a new family of pesticides based on nicotine. Nicotine occurs in tobacco plants as a natural insecticide.

The City of St. Paul's EAB Response Management Plan, contains an Appendix A which is an Imidacloprid Fact Sheet. While they do not say where they got the information it is clearly copied directly from the Sierra Club Canada Imidacloprid Fact Sheet. They city fails for not citing their source of the fact sheet. The original can be found online and includes all of the footnotes that are missing from the city's document. [Note to St. Paul: If you are going to rip of someone's work and include it in your document and the text contains footnotes it makes you look dumb to not include the footnotes you are supposedly citing.] Of interest in the fact sheet are the following passages.

"Imidacloprid is toxic to birds and wildlife and mildly toxic to fish. Imidacloprid use has been linked to eggshell thinning in birds[3], reduced egg production and reduced hatching success at exposures of 234ppm in food.[4] It is highly toxic to certain species including the house sparrow[5], pigeon, canary and Japanese quail[6]."

As far as bees are concerned, the report says, "Imidacloprid is an insecticide, so it is not surprising that it is toxic to many beneficial insects such as honey bees to which imidacloprid is highly toxic.[7] The widespread use of imidacloprid has been linked to colony collapse disorder, a phenomenon described by beekeepers, researchers and government officials when entire hive populations seem to disappear, apparently dying out. France has put restrictions on the use of imidacloprid (GauchoT) since the 1990s over concerns for the bee population."

The link between Imidacloprid and colony collapse disorder isn't really clear but caution is warranted.

I know there are bee hives on the St. Paul campus of the U of M for the agriculture fields. Since the fields are essentially right in the hot zone for EAB infestation I wonder how much pesticide has been used in the area and if there has been any affect on the bee colonies?

My concern is that residents who are not experienced in using pesticides will use them incorrectly and in doses that are harmful to the environment in an ultimately futile effort to save ash trees in their yards. Too many homeowners take the "more is better" approach to chemicals and really don't care what labels say.

~Kirk

Footnotes:

[3] U.S. EPA. Office of Pesticide Programs. 1994. Pesticide fact sheet: Imidacloprid. Washington, D.C., Mar. 18.

[4] U.S. EPA. 1992. Data evaluation record: NTN 33893 MRID No. 420553-13. Washington, D.C., Aug. 24.


[5] U.S. EPA. Office of Pesticide Programs. 1994. Pesticide fact sheet: Imidacloprid. Washington, D.C., Mar. 18.


[6] U.S. EPA. Office of prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances. 1994. Imidacloprid, acian 6(a) (2) submittals. Memo from A.F. Mciorowski, Ecological Effects Branch, to D. Edwards, Registration Division, Washington, D.C.


[7] .S. EPA. Office of Pesticide Programs. 1994. Pesticide fact sheet: Imidacloprid. Washington, D.C., Mar. 18.


Read More

Monday, February 22, 2010

St. Paul to Ash Borer: Let the Battle Begin

Posted by Kirk
(photo credit: US Forest Service)

It seems like a lot of the efforts thus far in the new battle against the invasive emerald ash borer have been reactive on the part of St. Paul, Minnesota. This is completely understandable with a new invasion like this. At the end of January though, the city opened a new front in the battle and it may not be where you would expect. The heart of the Emerald Ash Borer infestation has been centered on the very westernmost part of St. Paul near the Minnesota St. Fair grounds and the University of Minnesota St. Paul campus. The announcement at the end of last month was that the city would begin cutting down trees on the far East side of the city. They will remove XXX trees in wards 5, 6 and 7. The city has almost 30,000 ash trees on boulevards alone and it is estimated that ash trees make up 30% of the tree canopy in the city. According to the city's management plan, there are around 120,000 ash trees on public lands in the city. Make no mistake. The Emerald Ash Borer being found in St. Paul is a very bad thing. The city is now trying to be proactive in containing the threat.

The current plan is to remove the oldest and unhealthiest trees in the city that would be most likely to succumb to the eventual spread of the pest. These trees will die anyhow in the next few years as the ash borer spreads so by taking them out now the city not only gets a head start on their work but they hopefully will slow the spread of the borer by taking away trees that would be of use to the pest.

The reason for cutting down old trees proactively on the opposite side of the city from where the current infestation is located is that cutting down ash trees in the infected area would simply cause the bugs to spread further faster in search of suitable trees.

Trees have already been removed in the following areas:
Wilson Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Kennard Street
Reaney Avenue between Flandrau and Germain Streets
Hoyt Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street
Iowa Avenue between Kennard and Hazelwood Steets
Idaho Avenue between Flandrau and Germain Streets

Trees will shortly be removed on the following streets:
Walsh Street between Maryland and Magnolia Avenues
Magnolia Avenue between Payne Avenue and Walsh Street
Lawson Avenue between Weide and Arcade Streets
3rd Street between Germain and Flandrau Streets
Atlantic Street between Gotzian and 4th Streets
3rd Street between Earl and Atlantic Streets

The city is only removing boulevard trees and not trees on private property. Time will tell how the city's strategy pans out. You can download and read the city's entire management plan online. Eagan, Blaine, Minneapolis, St. Louis Park, New Hope, Minnetonka , and Cottage Grove have all also received money to help fight the spread of the beetle.

~Kirk
Read More

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Kiss your ash goodbye: Emerald Ash Borer found in St. Paul

Posted by Kirk


Image:Image: Gerald Wheeler/USDA:APHIS



The Minnesota Department of Agriculture reported this past week that the Emerald Ash Borer has been detected in Minnesota. This is awful news for both trees and the economy in the state. There are an estimated 900 million ash trees in Minnesota and these beetles could kill all of them. I checked on the ash tree in my front yard this weekend as I live less than a mile from where the Emerald Ash Borers were found. Best case scenario, they can move 4 miles per year so it is very likely there are already ash borers in my neighborhood. Uncontrolled, they can move about 18 miles per year.

How to tell if you have Emerald Ash Borers:

photos by: David Cappaert, USDA


1) Premature Yellowing

As trees come under attack the tree is weakened and leaves turn yellow long before fall. While there are a number of reasons trees can turn yellow early this is still a good warning sign. Any tree turning yellow early should be examined as there could be other problems that need to be addressed. With the Emerald Ash Borer the tree may also be completely devoid of leaves.



2) peeling bark
As beetle larva feed under the bark it can crack and loosen. Woodpeckers may also be attracted to the trees at this point. The tree has a diseased look. An old dying tree can look like this as well.









3) "D" shaped exit holes.
While the other signs may be an indication of some other type of disease or problem with the tree, the D shaped exit hole of the Emerald Ash Borer is diagnostic. (click to enlarge)






4) "S" shaped larval galleries.
This photo shows both a d shaped exit hole and an "S" shaped larval gallery. As the larval stage of the Emerald Ash Borer grows and feeds under the bark it snakes back and forth leaving this pattern. This photo is particularly interesting because you can actually see that the gallery is narrower at the bottom than the top. As the larva feeds and grows is bores a wider and wider path.





There is no way to stop the Emerald Ash Borer. Now that it has been found in the state all we can do is slow it down and kiss our ashes goodbye.

~Kirk

Read More